I've tested a variety over the last while looking for the best combination. A few of the quirks I found with different ones:
BitDefender: does not play nice with GMail - slows page loading enormously, seems solid otherwise
AVG8.0: firewall has less customization than in early versions, email scanner seems really slow
Panda: issues with email client eventually refusing to connect, have to reboot PC to get back functional - more pronounced on Vista than XP
Norton: failed to install properly - didn't bother to try to fight with it.
Kaspersky: liked it - customizable firewall, informative alerts, not excessively hard on the system overhead, useful options when a threat found.
Currently trying two free tools that rated well in PC World magazine - Avast Home antivirus (not sure how I like the VRDB yet) and Comodo Firewall (nags a LOT with popups until fully trained). ZoneAlarm also has free firewall that gives good customizability.
PC World had an article on how to construct your own security suite using free applications:
http://www.pcworld.com/article/150204/build_your_own_free_security_suite.html