What should I be looking for in chicken? (We have a Whole Foods)
Organic or "natural" chicken if you can find it. Personally, I don't have access to organic, so I use Nature's Promise chicken or FreeBird chicken.
...and be patient. Hopefully he'll gobble up chicken, but Sash may not take to real food right away. 14 out of my 16 cats will eat this recipe or just plain bits of cooked chicken or turkey or cooked Creekstone ground beef. My 2 exceptions were born to a feral momma cat and raised by humans since 3 days of age.