When I picked up Weruva today, I also bought a 6 can variety pack of B.G. (and "ANOTHER cat climber!" - DH). Will mix this in with the 15 cans of Weruva and report back on the "finiky felines taste test."

Lincoln and Disco both loved the Weruva Paw Lickin Chicken, the first sample in their treat food test today.

Day 1 of these purely supplimental foods began with feathers and ended with fins.  They shared a half can of turkey for breakfast.  Disco lapped up most of the liquid, as is her wont, and ate a little of the "mush."  Glad they tell you on the label it is only turkey and water - you would never be able to guess from the texture.  Just process turkey and water in your Cuisinart and save a trip to the pet food store.  Both cats left the dish before finishing and Lincoln, the manly Maine, complained vociferously that his dry food dish had mysteriously become empty. He did finally return to clean up the BG.  This pm the tuna literally swam onto their plate.  These 6 foods have from 76% to 78% moisture content.  Me thinks they'd rather snag a koi from the pond.  Put the fish and water in the Cuis.....you get the idea.  This is probably a very safe food, but does not please their discriminating palates the way last weeks Weruva test did.

LMAO at this soooooo funny.  SG Tuna is a sure fire thing inmy house too, when the Wellness just isn't working.

Well, they're still merrily chowing down on the Kibble - new large size bag opened last nite.

I guess I should knock wood. I think since the recall this is more bags in a row than ever that haven't changed in a negative manner or been rejected.

All 3, true to form, rejected the last can of chicken (they've eaten none of the chicken). The canned Quail is no longer liked by MK. Ling, as always, gets a bite, but now, she moves on to check for an option instead of eating it. She'll pout in the laundry room if nothing acceptable is forth coming. I guess that's one more wet off the shopping list.

All in all, I'd rather they ate this kibble than the FF, but I'd rather they had wet LOL.

Catch 22 rules still in effect...

Tried the salmon (canned) with 4 cats this AM.  (Cat #5 hates fish, so didn't try with him.)

Two rejected (typical--they reject most wet food.)

Other two ate eagerly.  BG Salmon will go on our list of foods for these two if no digestive upsets are noted later.  This seemed less watery than the chicken kind was, which is a plus (my cats won't eat watery food.)

Can anyone tell me why a food that is salmon and water is more brown than pink?  I was expecting a pink color like regular canned salmon...

I see packages of Atlantic Salmon in the grocery stores with a sticky label that says "Color Added".  I guess it sells better if it has a lot of orange color.  Great, more additives

Re:  Salmon  Try to buy wild caught Pacific Coast salmon.  No color needs to be added and the flesh is much firmer than Atlantic.  You'll only find fresh in certain areas, usually fall through spring, but even the frozen from stores like Trader Joes or COSTCO  looks and tastes much better than Atlantic.  Only things I miss from living on Puget Sound for five years are the salmon, clams, oysters and crab we used to go out to get.  Guess I'm just pickie like my cats. 

While I totally agree with you (had to copy the article into wordpad - apparently the eyesight is deriorating a bit - time for new glasses) - unfortunatley, some of us must opt for thw lower priced fish.  If one sees a compromise alternative here - I'm am all eyes and ears.